Winner is poster # 4!!! I dont know how to post the results from random.org to my blog (so if any of you do, please send me a comment with step by step instructions so I will know for next time. Thanks)
The winner was actually from an annon guest but they did an extra post to me with their email address and name and asked me to not post that.
So, CONGRATS, #4. I will forward your name and email address to Shutterfly and they will contact you directly with your promo code.